Main Menu New

Home > Advocacy > Critical Issues > Organic Animal Welfare Standards

Organic Animal Welfare Standards

 

USDA is seeking comments on the Organic Livestock and Poultry Standards proposed rule to strengthen organic animal welfare regulations. Comments are due by October 11, 2022.

In response to years of industry advocacy and a lawsuit filed by OTA, USDA published the Organic Livestock and Poultry Standards (OLPS) proposed rule on August 9, 2022. 
 


What’s at Stake?

Health and competitiveness of family farms – inconsistent animal welfare standards for organic chickens create an unlevel playing field for organic farmers already providing true outdoor access.

Advancement of organic animal welfare – 75% of Americans are either very or somewhat concerned about the treatment of animals by the meat and dairy industry.

Consumer trust and integrity of the organic label – 89% of Americans say the USDA should periodically review and update the organic standards to keep pace with new science and consumer expectations.
 


USDA Seeks Comments on Organic Livestock and Poultry Standards Proposed Rule

USDA’s Agricultural Marketing Service (AMS) is seeking input on the proposed rule with a comment deadline of October 11, 2022. AMS will held a virtual listening session on August 19 from 12 – 2 p.m. ET to hear oral comments.

Submit comments on behalf of your business or organization 

Submit individual comments as an organic consumer

Add your organization to the coalition sign-on letter to USDA

OTA Members and coalition partners: Submit the form below to get your Take Action Toolkit today! We’ve laid out how to submit your comments, provided full background on the issue, given you suggested talking points to consider, and offer up ways to get your thoughts out on social media and to rally support.


What's in the Rule? 

OLPS clarifies the production standards of avian and mammalian livestock as authorized by OFPA to support consistent enforcement across producers and alleviate market failure by assuring consumers that USDA-certified organic livestock products meet a robust and uniform standard. The proposed rule:  

  • Establishes poultry indoor and outdoor space requirements and stocking density limits. Enclosed porches are not considered outdoor spaces. 
  • Clarifies living conditions, healthcare, transportation and slaughter practices to support animal welfare for mammalian livestock species. 
  • Acknowledges that current conditions are causing consumer confusion and market failure. 
  • Adopts the position that the Organic Foods Production Act provides the requisite authority for regulations regarding livestock and poultry health care practices and living conditions – including regulations regarding animal welfare. 

“After 20 years stuck in limbo, organic animal welfare reforms are finally back on the agenda at USDA,” says OTA CEO & Executive Director Tom Chapman. “The Organic Trade Association welcomes the release of the Organic Livestock and Poultry Standards proposed rule, which will level the playing field for organic producers and raise the bar so that the highest standard of care becomes the baseline.”

Read the full press release

NOP’s OLPS Website

OLPS 2022 Proposed Rule Summary OLPS 2022 Proposed Rule Full Text 

Background 

Organic livestock and poultry producers have been clamoring for more robust animal welfare standards for nearly 20 years – almost as long as the Organic Foods Production Act (OFPA) has existed. The current USDA National Organic Program regulations require that all certified organic operations give their animals “access to the outdoors, shade, shelter, exercise areas, fresh air, clean water for drinking, and direct sunlight.” Unfortunately, these regulations have not been consistently enforced, resulting in some large companies utilizing narrow, enclosed porches for poultry instead of true outdoor access to meet this requirement.

After years of public engagement in the rulemaking process, The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) published the Organic Livestock and Poultry Practices (OLPP) in 2017, only for it to be abruptly rescinded by the Trump Administration. In response, OTA filed a lawsuit against USDA (ongoing). In response to the lawsuit and continued pressure from the organic industry, USDA  published the new proposed version of this rule – the Organic Livestock and Poultry Standards (OLPS) – and is currently seeking comments.  

Animal Welfare Regulation History
no

Blue

Main color: 
#1eb9d2
Hover: 
#4edaf0
Active: 
#078fa5
Title: 
#ffffff
Title Hover: 
#ffffff
Title Active: 
#ffffff
261
Animal Welfare Regulation History

Timeline

1995 – 2000 │ NOSB releases recommendations on animal welfare

2002 │ Organic regulations are implemented that include healthcare practices, outdoor access and living condition requirements for livestock

2002 │ A sustained appeals decision results in inconsistent application of the outdoor access standards for organic poultry

2010 │ USDA OIG releases an audit identifying inconsistencies in outdoor space for organic livestock

2011 │ NOSB adopts a set of recommendations to define further, clarify and incorporate production practices for organic livestock to advance animal welfare

2016 │ USDA releases Organic Livestock and Poultry Practices (OLPP) proposed rule

2017 │(Jan.) USDA issues final OLPP rule

2017 │(Feb.) Trump administration delays the effective date of the OLPP final rule

2017 │(Sep.) OTA files a lawsuit against USDA for failure to put the new organic livestock standards in effect

2018 │ USDA withdraws the OLPP regulation

2021 │ Biden administration indicates their interest in reconsidering OLPP and plans a new rulemaking process

2022 │ USDA releases new Organic Livestock and Poultry Standards (OLPS) proposed rule

Contact
no
column-1
30px

Contact


Johanna Mirenda
Farm Policy Director
(202) 812-7704